People over Product: Understanding the People-Centric Nature of the Service Industry

In the service industry, the adage "people buy from people, not companies" is an undeniable truth. The essence of service lies not in the product itself but in the human interaction accompanying it. This human-centric (or people-centric) approach has deep historical roots and significant contemporary relevance, as demonstrated by the evolution of the service sector, particularly in the United States.

Some Historical Context

The emphasis on people over products in the service industry can be traced back to the early days of commerce. In ancient marketplaces, the relationship between the merchant and the customer was paramount. A merchant’s reputation, trustworthiness, and ability to connect with customers often determined their success. This personal touch, the human element, was the cornerstone of trade and commerce.

As we move forward to the Industrial Revolution, we see a clear shift towards mass production and the commoditization of goods. Despite this, companies that excelled in customer service, such as Sears and Roebuck with their mail-order catalog or Nordstrom Department Stores with their “whatever it takes to make the customer happy” approach, outperformed their competitors. They understood that the customer’s experience, supported by attentive service from real people, was as crucial as the quality of the products offered.

Contemporary Relevance

Today, the service sector dominates the U.S. economy, employing seven out of ten American workers in the non-farming private sector. These workers are engaged in various activities, from healthcare to hospitality, each requiring a human touch that no product can replicate. The COVID-19 pandemic underscored this reality when service spending shrank by 20 percent between February and April 2020, only to bounce back as consumers yearned for human interaction and experiences.

Whether one buys a Ford, General Motors, or other company’s product may be based on brand loyalty, but whom one buys that new car from is almost always due to past experience or a reputation for great personal service and professionalism from its people. It is the same reason I prefer the same hotel brands and locations, the same restaurants and servers, and the same airlines when traveling. These are the places I trust because of their service.

Why People Matter More

Emotional Connection

Services often involve an emotional component, whether it’s the comfort of a familiar face in a local restaurant or the reassurance provided by a competent and compassionate technical support advisor to lead one to a resolution. These emotional connections cannot be replicated by products or “bots” alone. The unique value of human interaction in services creates bonds that are essential for customer loyalty and satisfaction, and it's a value that cannot be overstated.

Customization and Personalization

Services can be tailored to individual needs in ways that products cannot. A skilled service provider can adjust their approach based on the customer’s feedback, creating a personalized experience. This level of customization is critical in meeting diverse customer preferences and enhancing the overall service experience.

Problem-Solving

Successful service providers are inherently problem solvers. They can think on their feet and offer solutions that a static product cannot. This adaptability is crucial in meeting customer needs and building personal or brand loyalty. The ability to address and resolve issues in real time sets service providers apart from product-based businesses.

Trust and Reputation

In the service industry, trust is everything. Customers return to businesses where they are treated well and where they trust the people providing the service. While a product might initially attract a customer, it is the quality of service that keeps them coming back. Building and maintaining trust through excellent service is fundamental to long-term success because, over time, most customers will eventually have a bad experience. The equity built by a company through many positive interactions with its people will provide the customer with the confidence that one bad interaction is not the norm.

Value Perception

The perceived value of a service is often linked to its price, but it is the quality of the product and the service that determines whether customers feel they have received their money’s worth. As Bain & Company notes, "perception beats reality in pricing," and perceived value is often the determining factor in a purchase decision. The service quality, therefore, plays a pivotal role in shaping customer perceptions and driving repeat business.

The Bottom Line

While quality products are essential, it is the people behind them that truly make a difference in any service industry. The historical and ongoing success of service-based businesses underscores the importance of human interaction, personalized experiences, and emotional connections. As we continue to navigate a world where services are increasingly valued, the human element remains the irreplaceable core of the service industry. This focus on people ensures that the service sector continues to thrive, driven by the fundamental human need for connection and personalized care.

If you need any additional help or information, RWSmith ETC, LLC is just an email away. RWSmith ETC offers a variety of soft-skill classes designed to empower your staff and build a better workforce. You can learn more about specific class offerings by clicking HERE.

AI tools like ChatGPT and Copilot were used to help create this blog post.

Do you have questions or comments? Share below or contact Roger at roger@rwsmithetc.com.